What to do if your needs go over 50%
1 min read
If rent, transportation and groceries already take more than half of your take-home pay, you're not doing anything wrong: in many cities that's normal. What you need is to adjust the split without letting savings drop to zero.
The example
- Take-home pay:
- US$20,000 a month
- Needs today:
- US$12,000
- Wants today:
- US$5,000
You save US$3,000: needs are US$2,000 over your split.
50/30/20 split
- Needs
US$10,000 · 50% - Wants
US$6,000 · 30% - Savings
US$4,000 · 20%
What you spend today
- Needs
US$12,000 · 60% - Wants
US$5,000 · 25% - Savings
US$3,000 · 15%
First, take what's missing from wants, not from savings. A 60/20/20 split keeps savings the same even if your needs go up.
Next, look at your big needs: rent, transportation and debt payments. Lowering just one of them usually moves more than cutting many small wants.
If it still doesn't add up, start with a little savings, even 5%, and raise it every time your income grows.
Frequently asked questions
Is it bad to have needs at 60%?
No. The rule is a starting point; what matters is that savings don't disappear.
What should I cut first?
The wants you use least. Then look for a way to lower a big need, such as rent or transportation.
Sources
- Split compared with current spending using the 50/30/20 rule.
Calculate yours
Calculate my budgetRelated guides
What is the 50/30/20 rule
How to split your monthly take-home pay between needs, wants and savings, with an example.
Needs or wants: how to tell them apart
A simple question to tell whether an expense is a need or a want, with examples of each.
Did this help?